My First Submission to McSweeney’s
A letter from a major motion picture studio.
Dear Mr. Miller,
After having received correspondence from your aunt, my staff has diligently dug out your submissions for consideration in potential movie plots. Please understand that we deal with 100’s of submissions a day, often complete scripts with potential names attached. I did take some time out of my schedule to read and re-read your work in order to give you some constructive, if not obvious, criticism.
My Mother, your aunt, was very clear about not being too harsh in my statements. In order to be clear, if I seem dismissive or perhaps sarcastic, it is not you or your well-intentioned idea, it is the several hundred other Bruckheimer-wet-dreams I have to read every week which are just like it.
I am organizing your submissions by date and will refer to them by number for criticism. I have listed eight of the nine submissions, with the last one being dealt with in the general comments.
#1. This is a topic covered in several movies, with death and destruction of the Earth being rather trite. I do like the use of Bud, of Air Bud fame, for the lead. However, without articulated thumbs, I think that flying even a modified space shuttle is out of the question. To allay your concern, the budget for a bone-shaped asteroid wouldn’t be that high, but the afterthought “Cat Ninjas,” may present more of a challenge.
#2. You are right, no one has really thought about Zombies in the context of the north pole march. The intersection of these two genres could be lucrative, with global warming being a, pardon the pun, hot topic and some celebrity groans it might have legs. My assistant tells me that Penguins come from the South pole, so we may need a change of location, which means landfall in the south. Nothing movie worthy down there. Can penguin zombies surf?
#3. We are in contract litigation with both of those actors at the current moment, and as much as I would like for them to “bump uglies” on the big screen, this is not a plot idea. Unless you’re Zalman King.
#4. Once again, sex should not be the only thing that you are making a movie around. Also, the adult film industry covered this as soon as Brokeback came out. Yes Salma Hayek is hot, but I don’t think Frida will be the beginning of any type of carpet-anything career, even with “that hottie from Enterprise.”
#5. There is already a new Die Hard movie in the works and Indiana Jones lived in the early 20th century, they could not just happen to be in the same bar unless it is at a geriatric care center. Also, the budget would be untenable, even with the “coolness of coincidence.”(the inspiration of that expression should remain a secret until they legalize it.)
#6. Dr. House is not a real doctor.
#7. The Japanese have this covered, they make more “buddy cop” movies than we do. Also “jujitsu and shit” is not a martial art, so there would be no cage matches in it. Maybe with some research you could come up with a REAL martial art that has “ring hotties” and encourages people to bet with human/animal hybrid slaves.
#8. Franco-Prussian melodrama is a no-no, and a girl you just met at the bar may not have the acting ability to play anything except a skank. Do you have a head shot of her?
General Notes. “and shit” is not descriptive, research what you want to say. Originality is a good thing, perhaps you should expand your cultural digging ground beyond pirated movies and Maxim magazine. Your #9 submission was to short to consider even a movie idea; “A horse movie…” is more of a genre than a film and “with dwarves” is neither politically correct nor original.
I am very busy this time of year with contract negotiations and complete scripts to read, so please let your aunt know that responded to your submissions. From now on, please pass them on to her to read and critique first and she can pass them on to me. Despite her protestations that I have completely forgotten about her, the 11 messages on my voice mail per day constantly remind me she’s there. I will pick them up from her after a few rounds of edits this thanksgiving.
Yours Sincerely,
John William Caravace,
Duckhammer Films